Auditing auditor identities : Auditor attributes, professional and commercial orientations, and the implications for audit practice

Abstract: Currently, auditors face changes in the auditing industry, which has increased the focus on marketing activities. Despite professional ideals, an increase in the commercialization of audit firms has been observed, shaping the identity of the auditor. Auditor identity has been found to be a driver for commercialization, but certain studies find commercialization to be negative for audit practice. We argue that individual auditor attributes can explain orientations in the auditor identity, which in turn could have implications for audit practice. The purpose of this study is to describe and analyze how auditor attributes are related to professional and commercial orientations, and how the various orientations are related to audit practice. The theories used in this study are agency theory, social identity theory, and the theory of professions. We employ a quantitative survey method, with a questionnaire sent out by e-mail including questions about attributes, professional and commercial orientation, and reduced audit quality acts. Our results indicate that a positive relation to professional orientation exists for attributes adaptability and marketing skills. A positive relation for commercial orientation exists for the attribute marketing skills, while a negative relation exists for communication skills. Our results suggest that commercial orientation has a positive relation to auditors’ propensity to engage in RAQ acts. We find that knowledge has a negative relation to RAQ acts. A weak positive relation exists between adaptability and RAQ acts. The degree to which these results explain professional and commercial orientation and RAQ acts is small, why more research is needed.