Studying the Relationship between Architectural Smells andMaintainability

Abstract: In recent years, there has been a surge in research on theimpact of architectural smells on software maintainability.Maintainability in turn encompasses several other qualityattributes as sub-characteristics, such as modularity andtestability. However, the empirical evidence establishing aclear relationship between these quality attributes andarchitectural smells has been lacking. This study aims to fillthis gap by examining the correlation between sevenarchitectural smells and testability/modularity across 378versions of eight open-source projects. A self-developedtool—ASAT—was used to collect data on architecturalsmells and metrics relating to modularity and testability. Thecollected data was analyzed to reveal correlations at both theproject-level and within packages. Contrary to expectations,the findings show that, generally, there is no negativecorrelation between smells and modularity at the projectlevel, except for the Dense Structure smell. Remarkably,project-level testability showed the opposite result.However, a rival explanation proposes that the increasingsize of a project may be a stronger factor in this relationship.Similarly, package-level smells, as a whole, did not exhibit anegative correlation with testability. However, most smellsdemonstrated a stronger negative relationship with thequality attributes they were claimed to impair, incomparison to their counterparts. This empirical evidencesubstantiates the assertion that specific architectural smellsindeed relate to distinct quality attributes, which hadpreviously only been supported by argument.