Investigating reading comprehension in Reading While Listening and the relevancy of The Voice Effect

Abstract: Various forms of multimedia learning have been shown to aid learners time and time again. One form of multimedia learning that has not been thoroughly studied is reading while listening (RWL). This is especially the case when it comes to the immediate impacts on reading comprehension from practising RWL. Furthermore the recent advancements of Text-To-Speech (TTS) have started to challenge the established notion that real human recorded spoken word is always preferable for learning, also known as The Voice Effect. This study looked at Swedish University students with English as their second language (L2) and examined how their reading comprehension in L2 was performing in three different groups. The groups were Reading Only (RO), Reading-While-Listening with spoken word (RWL-SW) and Reading-While-Listening with text-to-speech (RWL-TTS). The RO group was then compared to The RWL groups. The two RWL groups were also compared on test scores as well as perceived enjoyment and aid from the narration as reported by the participants. Our results did not exhibit any statistically significant difference in reading comprehension between the RO group and the RWL groups. When looking at the results of the reading comprehension test the RO and RWL-TTS groups got the exact same number of correct answers. This suggests that RWL did not have any notable impact on reading comprehension. Furthermore no statistical significant difference was found between the two RWL groups in test scores or perceived enjoyment and aid from the narration. What’s interesting to note is that RWL-SW performed slightly worse than RWL-TTS on the comprehension test. The reported perceived enjoyment and aid from the narration was also notably similar to each other. This suggests that The Voice Effect did not have relevance in this test.